University calendar

Evaluation of changes in fishery independent surveys and sampling design in response to offshore wind energy development

Tuesday, December 22, 2026 at 9:00am to 10:00am

SMAST East 101-103 : 836 S. Rodney French Boulevard, New Bedford MA 02744
Callie Rumbut
c.rumbut@umassd.edu
https://umassd.zoom.us/j/94179982962

Department of Fisheries Oceanography

PhD Dissertation Defense
"Evaluation of changes in fishery independent surveys and sampling design in response to offshore wind energy development"
By: Catalina Roman

Advisor: Gavin Fay (UMass Dartmouth)

Committee Members

  • Steven X. Cadrin (UMass Dartmouth)
  • Adam Delargy (UMass Dartmouth)
  • Catherine Foley (NOAA NEFSC)
  • and Kathryn Ford  (NOAA NEFSC)

Tuesday December 22, 2026
9:00 AM
SMAST East 101-103
836 S. Rodney French Blvd, New Bedford
and via Zoom

Abstract:

As offshore renewable energy development expands, its interactions with long-term scientific surveys require adaptive strategies to ensure the continued accuracy and reliability of data used for management. In the Northeast US, the NOAA Northeast Fisheries Science Center's multispecies bottom trawl survey provides critical fishery-independent data for stock assessments and management advice. However, the increasing footprint of offshore wind energy areas presents challenges to survey continuity, potentially affecting data representativeness and introducing bias into abundance estimates.

This dissertation applied a spatially explicit multispecies simulation framework to the NEFSC bottom trawl survey to test alternative survey strategies under offshore wind development, using Scup and Summer flounder as case study species. Developed with input from two stakeholder workshops, the framework has four core components: a spatially explicit operating model simulating the population available to the survey, an observation model that replicates and modifies survey sampling designs, estimation models that produce alternative abundance indices, and performance metrics that quantify bias and precision.

Chapter 1 introduces the dissertation, discusses offshore wind energy development and explains the potential tradeoffs for marine environments and among ocean uses. The chapter reviews the current literature on how offshore wind infrastructure can affect vessel access and navigation, and the implications for fishery-independent surveys, with an emphasis on how changes in survey access and sampling design may affect abundance estimates.

Chapter 2 fits a spatiotemporal model of Scup to NEFSC bottom trawl survey data to estimate interannual variability in the spatial distribution of scup and a model-based abundance index. Results showed that predicted biomass was consistently concentrated along the Mid-Atlantic Bight and southern New England shelf, with variation in magnitude and spatial extent across years. The model-based abundance index followed similar temporal trends to the NOAA NEFSC BTS index but showed less variability, with differences in the magnitude of annual estimates. The predicted spatial distributions were subsequently used to distribute the simulated Scup population across the survey domain in the simulation framework developed in later chapters.

Chapter 3 develops the simulation model framework and applies it to assess the effects of survey preclusion and survey effort reallocation due to offshore wind areas relative to a Status Quo survey and compares design-based abundance indices with ratio- and model-based estimators. Precluding survey effort from offshore wind areas increased estimation error and variability, and uncertainty estimates did not fully capture the resulting loss of precision. Reallocating the precluded survey tows to accessible areas within the same initial strata, partly mitigated the effects of preclusion but did not restore Status Quo performance. Correcting estimates of abundance using ratios of tow abundance from outside and inside the wind areas prior to construction was the least stable approach, with higher variability across simulations and poor alignment between the estimated and empirical magnitude of uncertainty. In contrast, a geostatistical model-based estimator was more accurate and better represented the true changes in abundance. The effects of survey modifications varied by species and season with more noticeable reduction in estimation performance observed fir Scup during the fall and smaller effects for Summer flounder, especially in the spring.

Finally, Chapter 4 evaluated the use of supplemental sampling into abundance estimation to mitigate the effect of survey preclusion from offshore wind areas. An additional simulated survey, consisting of fixed sampling stations within wind-affected strata was used to evaluate three approaches: (1) pooling supplemental observations directly with the standard bottom trawl survey data, (2) applying stratum- and year-specific correction factors derived from supplemental observations to adjust survey abundance estimates, and (3) incorporating sampling source as a covariate in a spatiotemporal model. All three approaches reduced bias compared with survey preclusion without adjustment. Direct pooling and the model-based approach produced relatively low estimation errors, while direct pooling provided uncertainty estimates that more closely reflected empirical variability. The correction factor reduced bias but increased variability across simulations and underestimated empirical variability. The model-based approach also reduced bias and produced lower estimated uncertainty, but underestimated empirical variability, particularly for Summer flounder in the fall. A sensitivity analysis using an alternative selectivity function for supplemental sampling showed that differences in how surveys sample the population can reduce the benefits of restoring spatial coverage. These findings suggest that supplemental sampling can mitigate some effects of survey preclusion, but its effects depend on how observations from different sampling approaches are incorporated into abundance estimation.

Join Meeting
https://umassd.zoom.us/j/94179982962
Note: Meeting ID and passcode required. Email contact to obtain.

 For additional information, please contact Callie Rumbut at c.rumbut@umassd.edu

Back to top of page